Joe.co.uk logo

Play the JOE Pub Quiz

Joe media uk hamburger menu
NewsSportPoliticsEntertainmentLifestyleQuiz
FootballRugbyCricketMMAGolfBoxingBetting
sport
Share icon

Share

5 Candidates to replace Gary Neville on Monday Night Football

Published 15:59 2 Dec 2015 GMT

Mikey Stafford
5 Candidates to replace Gary Neville on Monday Night Football

Home›sport

Get our Pub Quizzes and latest news straight to you by clicking here »

Explore more on these topics:

Andy Townsend

Brendan Rodgers

Gary Neville

Monday Night Football

Paul Scholes

Roy Keane

Sky Sports

Thierry Henry

More from Joe.co.uk

FootballRugbyCricketMMAGolfBoxingBetting
NewsSportPoliticsEntertainmentLifestyleQuiz

Newsletter coming soon

Back to Top

More

About usPrivacy policyCookie policyTerms & conditionsContact us

Follow

InstagramFacebookYouTubeTikTokX

Contact

Contact usAdvertise with us
Log JOE Yellow

© 2026 Joe.co.uk or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Gary Neville will be missed on a Monday night. It has always been a very important slot in our telly watching schedule.

Some thought that Richard Keys and Andy Gray could not be replaced on Sky Sports' flagship Monday Night Football but then along came a knight in red armour - a footballer reviled by fans of all but one club who found his true calling explaining the game to the great unwashed. Yes, Gary Neville was the man to tell us just how sh*t Aston Villa are, or why an in-form Cesc Fabregas is so much less a liability than a jaded and knackered Cesc Fabregas. Along with his unlikely sidekick Jamie Carragher, Neville brought a level of erudition and sophistication to our Monday night football education but now it is lost, utterly lost. Carragher is going to need a new punditry partner, so we've had a look at a few of the runners and riders.

Thierry Henry

Pros: Infinitely more handsome than Neville (sorry Gary), the former Arsenal and Barcelona man could bring a level of French sophistication to bear on affairs. After a tentative start he is beginning to realise that having opinions, especially negative ones, is a good thing in this job. Cons: While he may be hiding his light under a bushel, there has been little evidence to date that Henry has Neville's ability to communicate tactical analysis to the viewing public.

Brendan Rodgers

https://twitter.com/DeludedBrendan/status/672029411810672640 Pros: Chiefly his availability and his unparalleled ability to talk, talk a lot. He would certainly back himself to slot into that tactical sensei thing Neville has had going on. It would be a privilege to see behind the velvet curtain and witness the genius at work. Cons: Runs the risk of taking credit for the good periods of play he is asked to analyse. His take of Jurgen Klopp's Liverpool could go one of two ways, while Sky Sports would be unlikely to take a punt on a man who clearly feels he has lots still to prove in the game.They would hate to lose another pundit so soon after Neville.

Andy Townsend

Pros: Now, bear with us here. Oodles of experience, currently on the lookout for a new gig and, while his ability to claim dual nationality is not so relevant in the global Premier League, Townsend has lots to offer. Namely passion. He really cares about the outcome of the games he is watching, almost so much that he forgets to offer anything in the way of analysis. Cons: May bring about the downfall of the English football economy by inspiring a mass cancellation of Sky Sports subscriptions.

Roy Keane

Pros: Pretty obvious, really. Unwavering thirst for the truth, unflinching hunger for conflict and inescapable death stare - the total package. Effectively employed doing the same job as the one Neville was doing with England, so there would be no problem with him slotting uncomfortably in there beside Carragher. Cons: There are still some questions about his tactical acumen after his disappointing spell at Ipswich. Unlikely to toe the Sky Sports party line and talk up 90 minutes of dross between West Brom and Norwich (which is another pro really).

Paul Scholes

Pros: Same as his former midfield partner Keano, just delivered with a drole Mancunian accent. Would keep up the Manchester United presence on MNF, while adding a violently anti-Louis Van Gaal element. Cons: Currently working at BT Sports, producing an endless stream of anti-LVG soundbites, his services would not be bought cheaply. Perhaps lacks Neville's enthusiasm for the tactical nuances - much like Keano, some times the very best footballers struggle to explain what it was that made them so great. It's a bit like asking Andy Townsend to explain punditry.

More from Joe.co.uk

The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 101

Molly-Mae drops major hint on new baby’s name and admits everyone’s ‘going to pronounce it wrong’

Molly-Mae drops major hint on new baby’s name and admits everyone’s ‘going to prono…

Apple's iPhone 16 Pro drops to one of its lowest prices ever in limited-time deal

Apple’s iPhone 16 Pro drops to one of its lowest prices ever in limited-time deal

Mikey Stafford
Most Viewed in sport
Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Football

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

Sport

The 2026 World Cup viral moments live blog: Follow all of the action in our hub

The 2026 World Cup viral moments live blog: Follow all of the action in our hub

Football

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Football

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

Football

More

News

Top Story

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Top Story

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

Football

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Football

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Football

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

Football

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

Top Story

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haal...

Man City threaten legal action after Real Madrid Erling Haaland transfer claim

The club have seen enough Manchester City have threatened legal action after a Real Madrid presidential candidate claimed that he could bring Erling Haaland to the club. As part of his president campaign, he stated on Spanish TV that the Norwegian striker had a release clause and wants to join the Spanish giants. Though the […]

5h

Football

5h

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Football

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

Football

AI predicts England route in the World Cup

Football

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Football

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

World Cup nation release statement as star player is denied entry into US

Football

Liverpool agree deal for Andoni Iraola

Football

Southampton manager Tonda Eckert personally speaks out on ‘Spygate’ for first time

Football

The Premier League club most impacted by VAR mistakes has been revealed

Football

Football

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

How the final Premier League table would look if every refer...

How the final Premier League table would look if every refereeing error was erased

Things would have looked very different. Every major refereeing decision leading up to the final few weeks of the Premier League season have been analysed, to establish how things may have played out differently, had PGMO officials always made the correct calls, in an impressive new report from the Athletic. The 2025/26 season ultimately ended […]

1 day ago

Football

1 day ago

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

Here’s why French fans riot – even when their team wins

It’s now an infamous tradition Following Paris Saint-Germain’s win in the Champions League final against Arsenal on Saturday, at least 780 people across France were arrested with more than 450 in custody, as football fans clashed with police. A person was found dead after an accident on Paris’s ring road, which rioters tried to block […]

1 day ago

Football

1 day ago

AI predicts England route in the World Cup

AI predicts England route in the World Cup

Football

England squad numbers leaked with big starting lineup hint

England squad numbers leaked with big starting lineup hint

Football

WATCH: Comical moment footballer is run over by his own medical team

Football