Share
19th May 2018
11:44am BST
"The thing every good leader should have is an instinct. Mine said to me: 'I don't fancy this.' When he came over to Old Trafford for the medical, I still had some indefinable doubt. He was very hail-fellow-well-met. Almost too nice."This character assassination was probably needlessly harsh, but it does arguably contain a grain of truth regarding Hargreaves' punditry. He does come across as "too nice", and rarely offers any criticism. Everything is "wonderful" or "exceptional" or "incredible." This makes Hargreaves a pleasant person but doesn't help his punditry. https://twitter.com/jacklang/status/862655962942976000 16. Steven Gerrard The new Rangers manager never seemed a natural fit for the punditry studio. https://twitter.com/btsportfootball/status/991806833709826048 15. Jamie Redknapp He is inoffensive, and doesn't offer a lot of insight. Redknapp works better when paired with Thierry Henry. Next to authoritative pundits - like Neville, Souness or Carragher - his views can feel lightweight. 14. Danny Murphy When we made this list last year, a good few people complained that we had omitted Danny Murphy. The former Liverpool midfielder is a good analyst and can break down how a game was won or lost when given the chance on Match of the Day. Some of his claims are questionable though. https://twitter.com/mrewanmurray/status/991949829424205824 https://twitter.com/CianByNature/status/995718263098281984 13. Thierry Henry Henry has been a pundit on Sky Sports for three years, he has worked on the biggest games and has had plenty of exposure. Yet, it doesn't feel like he has improved as a pundit. He is speaking in his second language, so we probably shouldn't be too harsh, but he hasn't become the star pundit Sky were hoping he would be. He can be quite bland, and his best punditry moments came on the BBC's coverage of the 2014 World Cup and Euro 2016, rather than on Sky. https://twitter.com/FootyThrowbacks/status/793230047859642369 12. Paul Scholes Scholes sometimes gives the impression that he would rather be doing almost anything else other than punditry. He also only seems to appear on BT Sport when Man United are playing. But when the mask of indifference and boredom slips and Scholes becomes interested in a game, he can be good as he often lacks a filter when expressing his views.
11. Jermaine Jenas
He is quite good on BBC radio and in his appearances on Match of the Day. Jenas isn't long retired and is in touch with the modern-day footballer.
10. Chris Sutton
The difficult second season. Last year, Sutton made an impression on football fans watching at home due to his contrarian approach, no-nonsense delivery and ability to wind-up his fellow pundits. He wasn't as effective last season, but he still divides opinion among viewers. In his appearances on BBC 5 Live in particular, he comes across as an intelligent and logical pundit, who can construct an argument.
9. Craig Bellamy
Sky tend to use Bellamy on their nightly show The Debate. He's easily the best pundit on the show and has impressed when covering live matches.
After Andy Carroll was linked with a surprise transfer to Chelsea in January, Bellamy said his former Liverpool teammate lacked the work ethic to excel at a big club.
Bellamy's view was both honest and refreshing, as most ex-footballers would have gone out of their way to avoid criticising a former teammate.
8. Ian Wright
Wright has improved as a pundit over the last few years. He is very good on both radio and Match of the Day.
His analysis of Christian Benteke's struggles at Crystal Palace last season was particularly informative. On MOTD, Wright said Benteke was lacking confidence and this manifested in his movement. He showed a clip of Benteke arriving too late for a pass into the box and then a clip of him jumping too early for a cross.
Wright used his knowledge from his career as a top striker to give an insight into how a current footballer was struggling, and the viewer learned something in the process.
7. Roy Keane
Is he insightful? Not really. Can he tell you how a game was won or lost? No. Is it mildly entertaining when he goes on a rant? Yes.
For that entertainment factor, Keane scores higher than many on in this table. No other football pundit cuts through bullshit like him and when he speaks football fans tend to listen.
6. Alan Shearer
Shearer has greatly improved since his early years as a pundit alongside Alan Hansen on the BBC. Gone are the days of him deploying the "say what you see" approach to punditry. Shearer now seems to take his role seriously and has justified his status as the BBC's main football pundit.
5. Graeme Souness
The Proper Football Man's Proper Football Man, Souness isn't to everyone's tastes but he is worth listening to. He speaks with authority. The former Liverpool captain also has no ties to the modern game. He doesn't know any of the players and he has no intention of returning to management. This frees him from worrying about potentially offending anyone.
Souness won't provide much tactical analysis but he's an effective counter-point to younger, more analytical pundits such as Neville and Carragher.
4. Rio Ferdinand
Rio has proved to be very good pundit. He is capable of articulating his experience of playing at the top level of football and relate it to the action on the field. Ferdinand also shines on BT Sport Show Premier League Tonight and is always worth listening to.
3. Frank Lampard
Lampard is articulate, intelligent and interesting. The former Chelsea midfielder is a natural as a pundit and comes across as though he has been doing the job for years. Lampard made a couple of appearances for Sky Sports in the 2016/17 season, and they arguably missed a trick by not signing him on a permanent deal. Lampard moved to BT Sport last season, and he has also worked on the BBC. He has been impressive on both.
His breakdown on Match of the Day of Jamie Vardy's stunning volley against West Brom was particularly excellent.
2. Jamie Carragher
The former Liverpool defender is articulate and a strong critical thinker. Carragher's work on Sky and his weekly newspaper column were essential staples for football fans throughout the season.
He also manages to combine the best qualities of his punditry peers. Carragher, like Neville, has a sharp analytical mind, he can cut through bullshit like Souness and is as quick-witted as Keane.
At his best, the former Liverpool defender is arguably the top pundit working on the Premier League.
He missed the last month or two over the undignified spitting incident. But, this list is based on each pundit's contribution last season, and on that criteria, Carragher has been excellent.
https://twitter.com/dionfanning/status/973273071015596037
1. Gary Neville
Neville remains the best pundit at analysing a game and informing the viewer at home about how it was won and lost, focusing on small details and putting them in the wider context. His experience at the top level of the sport gives him an authority to speak on the Premier League. More importantly, he can articulate this experience and knowledge and educate people watching at home.
However, since returning from managing Valencia, Neville has taken a step back from the Sky Sports studio. He is no longer a regular on Monday Night Football and his main contribution these days is as a co-commentator. He still does a great job in this role, but he isn't as present as he once was, meaning we see less and less of his tactical analysis pieces - which were a treat every week when he began working for Sky.
https://twitter.com/SportsJOEdotie/status/971012795402719232
Neville is also reluctant to criticise managers, and this can be frustrating for the viewer. It's possible that this is because of his experience at Valencia, or at United under Ferguson, where it didn't pay to question the boss, but it can arguably stunt Neville's analysis. Sometimes a team plays poorly because of how they have been prepared, rather than because of an attitude issue. His criticism of Arsenal earlier this season was extremely strong and somewhat justified - but he didn't direct any of his fury towards Arsene Wenger, the man who was employed to prepare the team.
But Neville is excellent, and any criticism is minor. Watching English football wouldn't be the same without him.
Here's the final table:
