
Entertainment
Share
Published 18:00 18 Jun 2025 BST
Updated 18:00 18 Jun 2025 BST

Prime Video has just added to its service We Were Liars, a new mystery psychological thriller adapted from the acclaimed 2014 young adult novel by E. Lockhart.
The series follows the wealthy Sinclair family, the extended members of which spend their summers each year on the idyllic Beechwood Island in New England.
The private island is owned by Harris (the great David Morse, Disturbia), the patriarch of the Sinclairs.
The show mainly focuses on Harris' teenage granddaughter, Cadence (Emily Alyn Lind, The Babysitter) and her tight-knit inner circle dubbed 'The Liars'. The group also consists of her two cousins, Johnny and Mirren (Joseph Zada and Esther McGregor), and family friend, Gat (Shubham Maheshwari).
One summer night on Beechwood, Cadence washes up on the shore, barely breathing and with a serious head injury - the trauma of which leaves her suffering from amnesia and migraines.
Unable to remember what happened to her, the teen returns to the island the following summer to get answers.
As the narrative switches between pre- and post-Cadence's injury, the question lingers: Do The Liars know more about what happened to Cadence than they are letting on?
We Were Liars boasts a great cast, which also includes Caitlin Fitzgerald (Succession), Mamie Gummer (True Detective) and Rahul Kohli (Midnight Mass).
JOE has watched the first episode of the series and is happy to report that there is a lot to enjoy in the show, from its gorgeous seaside setting, to its portrait of a dysfunctional wealthy family, to the sizzling chemistry between "will they, won't they" characters Cadence and Gat.
It's these elements, along with the lingering mystery as to how Cadence wound up unconscious on the beach, that will have us tuning in for more.
And based on other reviews - many of which have compared We Were Liars to Big Little Lies, Succession and The White Lotus - and comments from people who read the novel, viewers can expect some twists throughout the rest of the episodes.
This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission on any sales generated from it.
All eight episodes of We Were Liars are streaming on Prime Video right now.
Explore more on these topics:

The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 107
Entertainment

‘Rip-off’ contracts costing Brits £576 a year
Entertainment
The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 107

Entertainment
The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 107
Entertainment
‘Rip-off’ contracts costing Brits £576 a year
Entertainment
The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 106
Entertainment
Kit Connor and Joe Locke reflect on the emotional end of Heartstopper
‘The end of an era’ After four years, three series and a devoted global fanbase, Netflix has officially brought Heartstopper to a close with the feature-length finale, Heartstopper Forever. The film picks up directly after the events of series three and follows the couple as they face one of the biggest changes in their relationship […]
Entertainment
1 day ago
Claudia Winkleman confirms BBC chat show exit after one series
Claudia Winkleman’s Friday night sofa has been packed away The Claudia Winkleman Show has officially come to an end after just one series, with Claudia Winkleman deciding not to return for a second run. The BBC chat show, which launched in February, was created as a Friday night companion to The Graham Norton Show while […]
Entertainment
2 days ago
Entertainment
The JOE Film Club Quiz: Week 105
Entertainment